Hands on review of the Zenith Limited Edition Suarez

May 03, 2014,10:27 AM
 

When I was in Barcelona in 2013, my eyes were attracted by a very nice Zenith watch in the shop window of one of the most famous spanish dealer, Suarez. It was a contemporary Zenith chronograph with an original dial inspired by the past. A few days ago I was in Madrid so I decided this time to not miss the opportunity to see and to handle this watch since Suarez has also several points of sale in the capital of Spain. I didn't regret the time I spent with this watch since it is, in my point of view, one of the nicest limited editions of the last years.

Actually, this Zenith Limited Edition Suarez (20 pieces) is based on the Captain Chronograph. It is the reason why it shares several details with the watch of the permanent collection:
- its 42mm stainless-steel case diameter
- the two main hands and the hands of the sub-dials
- the pushers





But very quickly, a lot of differences become visible. I will obviously come back later about the dial but do you notice the shape of the second hand of the chronograph? Do you see the onion-shaped crown? Even the movement is not the same that we find inside the Captain Chronograph case. The Zenith Limited Edition Suarez is powered by the El Primero 4002 (while the Captain Chronograph uses the 400 B) which animates watches like the Pilot Chronograph, in other words, chronographs without a counter of the hours. The movement is visible thanks to see-through caseback. Don't expect any surprise here when it comes to the movement decoration: there isn't any, the watch stricly follows Zenith standards. Obviously, its performances remain classic in the El Primero context with a 5hz frequency and a power reserve of around 50 hours.

The most successful element which explains why this Limited Edition is so appealing is without any doubt the dial. Once again, the designers were facing the challenge to create a balanced dial with a 30mm movement inside a 42mm case. They managed to find this balance thanks to the "vintage" inspiration of the dial. It is not by coincidence if the choice was made to find the inspiration for the dial in a watch from, in my point of view, the 40s. This Limited Edition was created to celebrate the 70th anniversary of Joyeria Suarez which was founded in 1943 not in Madrid... but in Bilbao. Moreover, the watch celebrates the long partnership between Zenith and the dealer.





 
This dial is really beautiful. I appreciate a lot the peripheral scale which improves the readility, the shape and the colours of the figures which make me think in a way about the figures of the Pilot Type 20 GMT 1903 without the aging process but with a nice "patina" which matches the luminescent . But the main part of the character of the dial comes from the mix of the two snail scales which decorate it, make it very intruiging and creates the "vintage" atmosphere. The first scale, the ochre one, is a classic tachymeter. But honestly, I don't know what is exactly the second one in red with graduations between 10 and 40. All together, the dial looks very busy but it has a strong asset: the two subdials don't look too close to the center what they are though. The readability of the two subdials and primarily of the minutes counter remains acceptable.





The background of the dial uses a silver/grey grained colour which works very well with the scales and the figures. When I observed the whole of the dial, I was convinced by its coherence and its charm even it is not the purest around. But the big question is to know where the knot comes from. At the very beginning, I thought it was a sailing knot. I was totally wrong because at Suarez they explained me that the watch was inspired by a Zenith watch dedicated to an italian firemen corps. Anyway, the presence of this knot on the dial is quite original and it also contributes to the character of the dial.

On the wrist, there is no big surprise: I find again the same comfort than with the Captain Chronograph. The size of the crown makes its handling easier and as I wrote before, the readability of the chronograph data is decent despite the complexity of the dial. The biggest pleasure brought by this watch comes from the atmosphere it creates and the feeling to have an old chronograph on the wrist. It is the reason why this Limited Edition makes me think about a Limited Edition of a Zenith Class El Primero with a PG case released in the 90s which was displaying a telemeter and a tachymeter scales even if the two watches are not very similar.





Thanks to the staff of the Suarez boutique in Madrid for the warm welcome.

Pros:
+ the charm of the watch due to its "vintage" atmosphere
+ the shape of the crown
+ the dial finishings
+ the reliability of the El Primero movement

Cons:
- the dial could be perceived as quite confusing
- the movement is a bit too small for the case


Fr.Xavier
This message has been edited by foversta on 2014-05-03 10:31:16


More posts: El PrimeroLimited Edition SuarezPilotType 20 GMTType 20 GMT 1903

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

I don't know here...

 
 By: foversta : May 4th, 2014-01:58
Since the movement remains the El Primero and for commercial reasons, it is much better to make it visible. And since there is no specific context for the original watch, what kind of caseback decoration should you have put? Many times, for watches inspir... 

Come on, I understood what you said... but once again...

 
 By: foversta : May 4th, 2014-02:23
if you want to have the true spirit of the dial, buy a true vintage watch. At least this contemporary watch has other virtues like this visible movement which meets the expectation of the clients. Because in a collector's mind, nothing will replace the re... 

Then a pure marketting product?

 
 By: amanico : May 4th, 2014-03:04
For clients who need to see what's Inside their Watch, at the risk to see something which is not consistent with the era it si supposed to refer to. ( Dial is clearly inspired form the end 30ies, Mid 40ies ), while the movement is clearly inspired from th... 

You think like you are: a collector. But the world is not black or white...

 
 By: foversta : May 4th, 2014-03:36
I don't know what is a "pure marketing" product, I don't know what is a "honest" product, the only thing I can say is that the watches world is much more complex than this duality... Fx

"surprised by the feeling [...] that it is mandatory for clients to see what's inside"

 
 By: Ornatus-Mundi : May 4th, 2014-05:21
I'll take another edge o this: Why do all watch companies have the feeling that they are expected to release 'homage' models which are clearly inspired by the past. Where is the creativity to create compelling contemporary pieces? In a strict sense the Su... 

Agreed, Magnus. Tributes are meanless if there is the only way to go.

 
 By: amanico : May 4th, 2014-07:40
I mean, if the brands don't make some efforts on the innovative side. I finally don't get this Suarez, which is limited to 20 pièces, but not for Collectors ( as Collectors would point out the contradictions of this Watch ). I am looking forward to seeing... 

Innovation was not forgotten by Zenith these last years...

 
 By: foversta : May 4th, 2014-10:33
Just an example: the Christophe Colomb. And we also saw a lot examples of very contemporary designs like the Bullitt or the Lightweight. For me, since I think that there is no future for the Elite movement, the most important would be to have a larger ver... 

Focussing on the El Primero...

 
 By: Ornatus-Mundi : May 4th, 2014-13:33
and giving up on a second, highly regarded in-house movement, by a company that has a considerable reputation as movement manufacturer and has significant production volume, that leaves me a bit scratching my head... But I won't scratch too much because n... 

Magnus, you know the context of Zenith several years ago...

 
 By: foversta : May 4th, 2014-10:27
First of all, this LE is not on its own the summary of the full Zenith trend. Moreover, I think it was a good idea to celebrate the 70th anniversary of the dealer. If you look at the situation at the end of the Nataf period, there was a crucial need to be... 

Dear François...

 
 By: Ornatus-Mundi : May 4th, 2014-13:27
are you asking for marginal changes? A 'larger EP' - that's exactly what I do not expect from Zenith!!! That's the kind of 'innovations' which would put such a venerable house to shame. IF a give new movement would be larger BECAUSE there is a technically... 

Yes, it is what I expect from Zenith as a priority

 
 By: foversta : May 4th, 2014-14:07
A larger movement requires a full redesign of the movement. It is not a minor change! But the situation becomes urgent now. If you look at the 42mm case, the subdials location obliges to cut the scales which is a shame. So before thinking of... I don't kn... 

seeing your first pic I really thought it was something from 1960

 
 By: Bruno.M1 : May 3rd, 2014-11:02
I like it ! But is it so easy to order such small LE's ? Can every AD ask for 20 personalized watches ?

It depends the relationships the AD has with the brand.

 
 By: foversta : May 4th, 2014-01:59
When you have strong and long relationships with the brand, when there is a specific event here like the 70th anniversary of Suarez, I think that the agreement was easy to find. Fx

I did a double take

 
 By: Bill : May 3rd, 2014-11:16
I thought you were comparing an old model to something new then I realized "Vintage Charm". Well executed. As Nico said a solid case back would keep more of the vintage lines. Great review. Thanks Bill

Thanks Bill.

 
 By: foversta : May 4th, 2014-02:14
But as I said to Nicolas, I don't think that a solid caseback would have been mandatory here. I was not surprised by the see-through caseback... since the EP is a nice movement to observe. Fx

*sigh* more made-up chronological "history"

 
 By: LouS : May 3rd, 2014-11:58
You are right about that knot. It IS a fishing knot. It is a trademark of Perret & Berthoud, precursor to Universal Geneve, registered in June 1929 and occasionally used on chronograph dials. It is known as the noeud de marine. I am not familiar with ...  

Very interesting...

 
 By: foversta : May 3rd, 2014-14:22
I would love to have a pic of the original watch... Actually, I would like to know why this symbol could be found on the original Zenith watch. Was the dial coming from P & B ? Anyway, thanks a lot for the explanations and pic! Fx

Plausible; found the model

 
 By: LouS : May 3rd, 2014-16:54
The lion's share of early Zenith chronographs came from Perret & Berthoud...or more correctly, Universal...or even more correctly, Martel, Universal's chronograph movement manufacturer. Zenith had no in-house chronograph until it purchased Martel in 1...  

Thanks a lot LouS! You helped me a lot with this picture!

 
 By: foversta : May 4th, 2014-01:52
Thanks for all the info you brought. I tend to agree with you, the context of the original watch is unclear... anyway, I still think that the contemporary watch is nice! ;) Fx

Could you elaborate bit...

 
 By: Ornatus-Mundi : May 4th, 2014-13:36
on why you think the story appears to he a 'dog's breakfast' to you? All I have read so far seems like standard operation procedure some decades ago to me ... Thanks, Magnus

I wasn't referring to the original 1924 watch

 
 By: LouS : May 4th, 2014-15:39
I was talking about the El Primero-powered homage of a 1920's watch inscribed to an Italian Lieutenant Colonel made for a Spanish retailer with Universal Geneve dial markings and a background story about firefighters. THAT is a dog's breakfast.

Yes, my dog would love it! ...

 
 By: Marcus Hanke : May 7th, 2014-02:17
... You showed a great research work here, Mr. Holmes! :) Marcus

.

 
 By: Epilogue : May 3rd, 2014-15:11

I think the red scale may be a "telemetre"...

 
 By: Epilogue : May 3rd, 2014-15:13
...or "rangefinder" in english. Used to calculate distance using sound. Like calculating how far a storm is according to the difference between the lighting and thunder. Again, not sure about this...

Dear Epilogue, for me it is not a telemeter scale...

 
 By: foversta : May 4th, 2014-01:55
It was a hypothesis I looked at but for me it is not. Thanks! Fx

I believe it is a tachymeter scale, too ...

 
 By: Marcus Hanke : May 7th, 2014-02:36
... but for calculating the speed in knots, based on maritime miles (1.85 kilometers), instead of kilometers. I thought on that when reading about the Italian officer, and at a rough estimation, the scales correspond between 60 km/h for one kilometer per ... 

Not sure what to make of this one

 
 By: Spellbound : May 3rd, 2014-15:48
It feels like a mix and match of pieces from their current collection. Numerals and crown from the Type 20's and case, hands and dial from the Captain. It certainly would be interesting to see the original inspiration for this watch. Thanks for the report... 

I like it

 
 By: optionc : May 3rd, 2014-23:39
While I understand the comments from the others... It does speak to me. Nice execution. I wonder how difficult to get one in Hong Kong given it is for Suarez. That's a long trip to pick up a zenith! OpC

Thanks Optionc!

 
 By: foversta : May 4th, 2014-01:54
A reason to fly to Madrid and to enjoy some nice restaurants? Fx

Well played and a nice suggestion.

 
 By: optionc : May 4th, 2014-08:46
I have never actually been to Spain before... strange for me to say that as I've been on planes traveling for business much of my adult life. So --- another great reason to visit! OpC

One of the nicest Zeniths, imho ...

 
 By: Marcus Hanke : May 7th, 2014-02:37
... and I would definitely prefer it over the Pilot series. Marcus